WELCOME TO SCIENCE LESSONS THAT ROCK
  • HOME
  • Blog
  • About Me
  • Shop
  • Let's Connect!

Cell Size Lab: Examining Surface Area to Volume Ratios

11/5/2018

4 Comments

 
Cell size lab from Science Lessons That Rock
Why are cells so small? And why are we made of so many? It seems like it would be easier to be made of 100 or even 1,000 cells instead of trillions. One of the reasons we teach students that cells are small is because they need a large surface area to volume ratio. The larger the ratio, the more efficient the cell is at moving materials in and out of the cell.

I've seen cell size labs that use different sized agar cubes prepared with a pH indicator. The cubes start pink and lose their color as they soak. (Here is a free version from Flinn if you are feeling ambitious!) Frankly with 3 preps a day this year, I didn't have the time or energy to pour agar cubes. Instead I found a quick and easy way for students to see the same concept- using beets and bleach.

In this experiment, cut different sized beet cubes, a small, a medium, and a large. The students soak the cubes in bleach for roughly 30 minutes (I had them doing some practice SA:V calculations while they waited). Tip: if you use tupperware containers with lids you won't have to smell bleach fumes all day, or you can put parafilm over the beakers.
Cell-size-lab-directions
surface-area-to-volume-cell-size
After 30 minutes of soaking, students remove the beets, cut them open, and measure the amount of red pigment remaining. It is an easy way to see that small cells are more efficient at moving materials in and out. If you are interested in seeing the lab write-up I wrote, you can view it here.
I hope your students enjoy it!

4 Comments
Cassondra
8/21/2020 07:20:20 pm

Is it possible to do this lab with a solution other than bleach? Bleach isn't permitted in Biology classrooms in my school for safety reasons; the Chemistry teachers have to keep it under lock and key.

Reply
Thomas
9/18/2020 12:40:18 pm

Maybe potatoes and iodine? I know iodine comes with its own restrictions, but you can likely buy it at a pharmacy (when I was a kid we used to use it as a disinfectant). Then again, when I was a kid we used to treat a fever with a course of leeches.

Still - should be doable using potatoes and iodine. I am going to try it this year in remote teaching mode.

Good luck!

Reply
Lisa
10/2/2020 08:29:50 pm

Same here! Vinegar works great as a substitution for bleach in this lab.

Try using that!

Reply
Dominique
10/28/2020 03:29:11 pm

Just an FYI. I tried this with vinegar and it doesn't work. The beet loses pigment and the vinegar changes to a pink color, but no visible change in the beet.


Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Becca 
    The face behind Science Lessons That Rock

    I'm a teacher, blogger, and curriculum writer.
    I've been teaching science for 12 years at both the middle and high school levels.

    Categories

    All
    A List Of ALL Blog Posts
    Astronomy
    Back To School
    Biochemistry
    Cells
    Chemistry
    Classroom Decor
    Classroom Management
    Distance Learning
    Ecology
    End Of The School Year
    Evolution
    Experiments
    Field Trips
    Forensics
    Formative Assessment
    For NEW Teachers
    FREE Stuff
    Fun Stuff
    Genetics
    Geology
    GIveaways
    Holidays
    Literacy
    Media In The Classroom
    Metrics
    Microscopes
    Physics
    Plate Tectonics
    Projects
    STEM
    Sustainability
    Teacher Tips
    Technology
    Test Prep
    Water
    Weather And Climate

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • HOME
  • Blog
  • About Me
  • Shop
  • Let's Connect!